Ryanair’s ownership structure is at the centre of a fast-track Commercial Court case in Ireland after a trade association alleged that the airline does not meet European Union requirements governing airline ownership and control.
On Monday, Ms Justice Eileen Roberts rejected an application to add Lufthansa, KLM and Air France as named parties. The judge said their inclusion would complicate proceedings that are already subject to an agreed timetable. She did, however, allow the three airlines to provide affidavits in support of their positions.
The litigation was brought by the Amsterdam-registered European Network Airlines’ Association (ENAA) against the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA), with Ryanair participating as a notice party. ENAA says it represents an EU regulatory framework intended to protect and promote the competitiveness of European airlines.
“It was a deliberate anti-competitive attack instigated by a limited number of the applicant’s members, namely Lufthansa and Air France, in an attempt to ground an airline whose lower fares they cannot match.”
The words were contained in an affidavit from Ryanair chief executive Michael O’Leary, which was referred to during Monday’s application. O’Leary also said the proceedings were designed to limit the ability of EU airlines to raise capital from outside the bloc. He linked the challenge to Ryanair’s criticism of what he described as years of illegal state aid received by Lufthansa and Air France.
The ownership issue before the court
ENAA’s case concerns Air Services Regulation (EC No 1008/2008). The regulation requires that no more than 50% of relevant equity share capital in an EU airline is owned by nationals from outside the EU.
Ryanair disputes the allegation that it fails to comply. The airline’s position is that restrictions placed on non-EU shareholders mean those investors have no rights to attend, speak or vote at its annual general meetings. Ryanair therefore says its arrangements satisfy the regulation.
- Applicant: European Network Airlines’ Association
- Respondent: Irish Aviation Authority
- Notice party: Ryanair
- Proposed named parties: Lufthansa, KLM and Air France
The court’s ruling keeps the case on its existing timetable while allowing the individual airlines to put evidence before the court without becoming named parties. The dispute therefore remains focused on the interpretation and application of the EU ownership rules, rather than expanding into a broader set of proceedings involving the three airline groups.
For Ryanair, the case concerns the basis on which its ownership and shareholder-control arrangements are recognised for regulatory purposes. For ENAA and the airlines supporting its position, the proceedings address whether those arrangements comply with the ownership conditions attached to EU air-service rights.