Plans to extend the European Union’s Emissions Trading System (ETS) to more international flights have met opposition from Middle Eastern governments at a global aviation policy gathering held under the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). The dispute centres on whether regional measures should apply alongside the international Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA).
The EU proposal would bring flights to destinations within 5,000 kilometres of Frankfurt Airport into the bloc’s emissions regime from 2029. The existing ETS applies to flights within the European Economic Area, while the proposed change would extend its reach to services from Europe to airports in the Middle East and North Africa. Transatlantic flights to the United States would not fall within the proposed distance limit.
| Measure | Current or proposed position |
|---|---|
| EU ETS | Currently applies to flights within the European Economic Area |
| Proposed extension | Flights to destinations within 5,000 kilometres of Frankfurt Airport from 2029 |
| CORSIA | ICAO scheme covering rising emissions from international flights in most participating countries |
Saudi Arabia calls for a single global approach
Saudi Arabia urged ICAO member states to support a global response based on CORSIA and to reject overlapping emissions regimes. Kuwait, Qatar and Egypt supported the position. Saudi Arabia’s argument is that international aviation should not face multiple systems that could impose duplicate costs or create different compliance requirements for carriers operating across borders.
“duplicative or extraterritorial emissions trade schemes that will increase compliance costs”
The wording formed part of Saudi Arabia’s call for countries and regional organisations to avoid measures that overlap with CORSIA. Qatar separately proposed that ICAO carry out a technical assessment of the effects of the EU ETS on the international scheme.
European governments defend regulatory authority
Several European countries disagreed with the positions advanced by the Middle Eastern states. The disagreement reflects a wider split over how international aviation emissions should be regulated: airlines and many governments have backed CORSIA as a way to avoid a patchwork of national and regional schemes, while some European lawmakers and environmental organisations say the ICAO programme does not go far enough to cut emissions.
Under CORSIA, airlines in most countries buy offsets in environmental projects to counter increases in emissions from international flights. The system is therefore central to the industry’s effort to manage emissions beyond domestic or regional regulatory boundaries. The competing approaches raise questions over how carriers would account for the same international activity where more than one framework applies.
Costs and fuel availability remain central issues
The policy dispute comes as the airline industry seeks to meet its commitment to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050. Executives acknowledge that the target will be difficult to reach because of shortages of sustainable aviation fuel and continuing growth in passenger traffic. Airlines and most governments have warned that fragmented requirements could increase costs, while European lawmakers and environmental groups maintain that stronger action is required.
The ICAO gathering concluded on Friday after discussions involving governments and aviation stakeholders. Its debate over CORSIA and the EU ETS places the interaction between global and regional climate rules at the centre of future international air transport policy, particularly for services connecting Europe with the Middle East and North Africa.